The Papal Bull of 2015: Congress, Trump and worthless pontification

By Russ Imrie – September 2015 (first release on Sunday, of course)

With the Treaty of Tordesillas (1494) Pope Alexander VI mandated a line pole-to-pole through the Atlantic dividing Portuguese and Spanish claims in the New World.  Of course this was hugely controversial—and still is. Spain got a big chunk and Portugal got some islands. England and others thought it was all overreach and pretty much ignored it. The jury is still out on this but let’s move on shall we?

The Pope accomplished this feat by issuing a Bull, or declaration, that was finally formalized in a treaty in 1506 with some tweaks that pleased a miffed Portugal and assured posterity that Brazil would speak Portuguese and that the local Indian populations would not have a legal leg to stand on. (Part of this remains in effect, more or less, with indigenous Indigenous community researchers and activists developing strategies to rescind policies built on this shaky ground.) A more recent Pope has stirred things up again with declarations such as:

#1. Climate change and inequality are inextricably linked.

#2. The global economy must protect the Earth, our common home.

#3. Everyone must divest from fossil fuels and invest in the future.

#4. It’s time for powerful nations to pay their fair share.

#5. There’s no easy way out of this. (quotes from Pope Francis’ encyclical)

Now, is the office of His Holiness at it again? By using his Bully Pulpit (nice how that fits) and weighing in on the radioactive subject of humanity’s contributions to global climate change as cited in his encyclical of June 15, His Holiness has conservatives (many Catholic) and industry shills all over crying out “BULL!”[bull!]

Prominent among the bullsayers  is Donald Trump, perennial presidential primary candidate and prominent expert on everything including global warming and the acreage of the Papal  bailiwick. He shrewdly refreshed his global warming denial cred in his candidacy announcement June 16. The rest of the tattered GOP presidential candidate field touts its robust nomance with global warming as well.

But topping Trump has been Sen James Inhofe (R.-OK.), who chairs the powerful Senate Environment and Public Works Committee and hauled in a fresh Washington DC snowball (don’t miss my post on snowballs and the warming Arctic) and tossed it on the floor of Congress. With this stunt, Inhofe probably believes he decisively proved Global Climate Warming was a hoax (and perhaps cunningly shilled a bit for his book.) This particular snowball seemed to really get Inhofe rolling—as snowballs are wont to do. And the Bull rolls on…

Senator Inhofe (Liberal Arts BA at 40, bankrupted his insurance company) applied these skills to sermonize the Pope and says that the Pontiff (Masters in Chemistry) ought not talk about science, the climate, and so on. He says the Pope is wrong and that the planet’s poor need fossil fuels. But isn’t it the Pope’s job to discuss the world’s less fortunate and more vulnerable? And Inhofe’s job not so much? Meanwhile some of Inhofe’s staunchest money contributors are the Oil and Gas industry. They take umbrage at the Pope’s statements that put lucrative business under a cloud.

Oklahoma, Inhofe’s home state, has some of the lowest rates of belief that global warming is increasing dramatically and even higher skepticism rates that it’s happening with human help. No surprises there but whose bull are we to believe in? A reason-challenged legislator fiercely protective of his state’s extraction industries? Or maybe a Pope’s Laudato Si  phrased in delightful language rich in Catholic tradition and good advice, and that at the least, is no bull.

[bull!] “bull”, short for “bullshit”, an American colloquialism indicating a statement or action is outrageously nonsensical, deliberately misleading, and ridiculously dishonest, having little to do with reality in the eyes/ears of the listener, and often condemned as imbued with a deliberate measure of “spin” or an agenda.

distant US Capitol dome

U.S. Capitol SOTU eve, 2011 – photo Russ Imrie

Russell Imrie is a  Networking and Content Specialist, craft beer enthusiast, webmaster and an American Indian blogger living in the Washington DC area. For a decade Imrie built systems and lived totally off the grid in the Santa Cruz Mountains of California near Silicon Valley. More opinion pieces are at China Daily Mail (under nom de blog supTweet)

Copyright Russell Imrie 2015

One response to “The Papal Bull of 2015: Congress, Trump and worthless pontification

  1. Pingback: Super-sized tweets and news 4 networks and security policy | Suptweet's Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s